Cabinet minister's firms got campaign funds
Daphne Bramham
Vancouver Sun
October 7, 2005
Federal Liberal Multiculturalism Minister Raymond Chan
funnelled $4,900 from his 2004 election campaign into his own
companies, and another $3,600 to the treasurer of one of those
companies, a Vancouver Sun investigation has revealed.
Chan's campaign paid $3,400 to Greenwood Academy and Grand Canadian
Academy for advertising. Chan, MP for Richmond, owns Greenwood
Academy through a company called Grand Canadian. The school is in
Nanjing, China. All of its students are Chinese citizens. Hardly the
place a Canadian politician would go looking for votes.
That $3,400 is slightly more than Chan spent advertising on
Fairchild Radio's AM and FM stations combined, and it's nearly three
times more than he spent advertising in Ming Pao, the largest
Chinese newspaper in the Lower Mainland.
Greenwood's treasurer, Klement Mui, was also paid $3,600 by the
campaign for undisclosed services rendered in May and June of 2004.
Yet another Chan company, Global Business, was paid $1,500 for
rent, heat and light.
What's interesting about that is that Global didn't even bill the
campaign until October 2004 -- four months after the election.
Chan's conflict-of-interest disclosure says that he is sole owner
of Grand Canadian Academy Inc. and 70 per cent owner of Grand
Canadian Academy (Nanjing) Inc., two private companies that operate
a school in China, as well as co-owner of Global Business
Development Inc., "an inactive family company."
It's also interesting that all of the money paid to Chan's
companies and to Mui was listed among the unpaid claims in the
initial election expense report. However, Elections Canada says all
of those bills have since been paid.
What it adds up to is that Chan's companies and the company
treasurer got slightly more than $1 out of every $10 spent on the
campaign.
But that's not the end of the story for Chan and the Nanjing school
After his re-election, Chan was appointed secretary of state for
multiculturalism. He had been secretary of state for the
Asia-Pacific before he lost in the 2000 election.
As multiculturalism minister, Chan was back on the Asia circuit and
his first major trip was to China in January 2005 with the Team
Canada trade mission. There, among other things, Chan helped open
doors for Michael Lo and Queenie Tin, the principals in Kingston
Education Group.
The New Westminster-based Kingston group operates Lansbridge
University, a private college with branches in Chan's Richmond
riding and another in New Brunswick. It also operates home-stay,
high school programs for Chinese students in Burnaby, Markham and
Niagara Falls, Ont.
In China, Chan toured Beijing University with Lo and Tin and was
there for the signing of a contract between Beijing University and
the Kingston group to offer joint on-line Master of Business
Administration courses.
The Kingston group also signed a letter of intent with Shanghai
Sibo Polytechnic College to promote academic cooperation and
exchange.
At the time, Lansbridge was not allowed to call itself a university
in B.C. However, a B.C. ministerial order in June granted it the
right to use the word "university" in its name.
A photo from the Team Canada trip of Chan, Lo and Chi Huisheng,
vice-chair of Beijing University, is prominently displayed on the
Kingston website along with a photo of the company's 2004 Christmas
party where Chan gave a speech along with Liberal MLA Patrick Wong.
(Lots of other politicians joined in for the karaoke and lucky
draws -- former Liberal MP Sophia Leung, MLAs Patty Sahota, John
Nuraney, Richard Lee, Vancouver city councillor Raymond Louie, and
Bill Cunningham, the senior adviser to the Liberal government in
Ottawa.)
The China photo is just below a press release about Kingston's new
high school program in Nanjing, with the first graduates being
awarded their Dogwood Certificates. This is the school formerly
known as Greenwood Academy, the only B.C.-accredited school in
Nanjing.
In March 2005, Lo and Tin renamed one of their numbered companies
Grand Canadian Academy (China) Inc.
So when did they buy into the school? That's not clear, since Chan
never disclosed to the ethics commissioner who owned the other 30
per cent of the school. And the B.C. government's Independent School
Inspector's office still lists Chan's company as the owner.
There's also another messy bit. Patrick Chun, Chan's original
partner in the school, wrote to Ethics Commissioner Bernard Shapiro
in February and provided him with documents that show him -- Chun --
as owning 40 per cent of the school and asked him to investigate.
Shapiro declined, saying it was a private legal matter and did not
fall within his jurisdiction.
But perhaps Shapiro should reconsider.
People who donate to political parties don't expect their money to
end up in the candidate's bank account -- personal or corporate.
And taxpayers, who foot a large part of the bill for trade
missions, don't expect cabinet ministers to be furthering their own
personal interests overseas.
But in these waiting days before Justice John Gomery reports on the
millions of dollars misspent on advertising contracts in Quebec, a
few thousand bucks here or there to the folks in Ottawa might just
seem like chump change.
And the sad truth may very well be that this is the way the game is
played in Canada.
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Copyright © 1985 to 2003 CanWest Interactive Inc. or its licensor. All rights reserved. CanWest Interactive Inc. is a subsidiary of Canwest Global Communications Corp. Reprinted with the permission of CanWest Interactive Inc. Any further reproduction or reprinting requires the permission of CanWest Interactive Inc.
|